Clinical guidelines as the legal basis for the criminal prosecution of a medical employees
https://doi.org/10.52485/19986173_2021_1_68
Abstract
Clinical guidelines developed by the professional community are actively used as an evidence base for legal prosecution of medical employees. The process of preparation, application and status of clinical recommendations remains unresolved, which is a significant factor in the withdrawal of doctors from the profession and the aggravation of personnel problems. It is proposed to postpone the implementation of clinical recommendations with the preliminary creation of a medical decision support system, an adequate legal review of these documents, and delimitation of the binding status of individual points of recommendations.
About the Authors
K. G. Shapovalov
Chita State Medical Academy
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Chita, 39А Gorky str., 672000
S. A. Sumin
Kursk State Medical University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Kursk, 3 Karl Marks str., 305041
R. A. Yaroslavkin
Bar Association of the Kursk Railway District, Kursk Law Chamber region
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Kursk, 42 Respublikanskaya str., 305000
References
1. Aleksandrova O. What threatens the medical organization for deviating from clinical recomendations.Pravovyevoprosy v zdravoohranenii. 2019. 4. 18-21. in Russian.
2. Bagmet A.M. Interrogation tactics in the investigation of crimes committed by medical professionals. Investigation of crimes: problems and solutions. 2017.1.25-31. in Russian.
3. Berezinsky V. Clinical guidelines have become mandatory. The main questions of the medical workers were answered by a lawyer. Pravovyevoprosy v zdravoohranenii. 2019.3.60-65. in Russian.
4. Dats A.V., Dats L.S., Sandakov P.I. Assessment of the quality of diagnosis and determination of the causes of acute renal injury in severe trauma. Zabaikalsciimedicinsciivestnik. 2018.3.21- 29. in Russian.
5. Knyazev B., Taevsky B., Taevsky A. Main changes for chief medical officers in 2019. How to restructure work and instruct subordinates.Zamestitelglavnogovracha. 2019.1.16-27. in Russian.
6. Matytsin N.O., Kolokolov A.V. Why follow clinical guidelines if they are not legally approved? Zamestitelglavnogovracha. 2017.868-69. in Russian.
7. Panov A., Korshunov A. Rules of communication with the investigator: how a doctor does not get under trial. Pravovyevoprosy v zdravoohranenii. 2018.7.30-42. in Russian.
8. Pecherei I. The Investigative Committee created special forces for doctors. How to prepare health workers to communicate with investigators.Zdravoohranenie. 2019.4.20-31. in Russian.
9. Piven D.V., Kitsul I.S., Ivanov I.V. On amendments to the Federal Law "On the Fundamentals of Health Protection of Citizens in the Russian Federation" on clinical guidelines: what to do and what to expect for medical organizations? Manager zdravoohraneniya. 2019.4.6-12. in Russian.
10. Starchenko A.A. When a physician can deviate from clinical guidelines. Master class from the insurer. Zamestitelglavnogovracha. 2019.962-68. in Russian.
11. Starchenko A.A. Round table "Surgery - a zone of professional and legal risk": legal nihilism and disregard for the rights and legitimate interests of patients. Manager zdravoohraneniya. 2019.10.48-60. in Russian.
12. Sumin SA, Legal consequences of an unfavorable outcome of treatment. Anesthesiologiya i Reanimatologiya. 2018.1.4-8.
13. Sukhorukikh O. How the law on clinical guidelines will change the work of medical organizations. Zdravoohranenie. 2018.12.14-19. in Russian.
14. Khmelevskaya E. Adopted a law on clinical guidelines. What will be required from the deputy. Zamestitel glavnogo vracha. 2019.2.78-83. in Russian.
15. The Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation dated 12/18/2001 No. 174-FL (as amended on 11/04/2019). in Russian.
16. Federal Law "On the Fundamentals of Health Protection of Citizens in the Russian Federation" dated 21.11.2011. No. 323-FL. in Russian.
Review
For citations:
Shapovalov K.G., Sumin S.A., Yaroslavkin R.A. Clinical guidelines as the legal basis for the criminal prosecution of a medical employees. Transbaikalian Medical Bulletin. 2021;(1):68-73. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.52485/19986173_2021_1_68
Views:
101
Email this article 